The Cookie Castle Co.

Freshly baked cookies with a sweet story and a taste of Aruba

The Cookie Castle Co. grew from siblings Matthew and Nicole who combined their love for baking with their lifelong connection to Aruba. Known for hand rolled gourmet cookies made with premium ingredients. The brand began when Nicole crafted dairy, nut free cookies that her family adored. In college, she launched the now iconic “Ultimate Duo” stuffed cookie. Matthew joined at a pivotal moment, helping expand from an online startup to nationwide shipping and retail shelves. Inspired by their late father, Steven Castles, whose grit and entrepreneurial spirit shaped their drive. With a lifelong love for Aruba, they brought their passion and sweetness to the “One Happy Island.

What to expect

• Freshly baked cookies made with high-quality ingredients.
• Allergen-friendly favorites, including the “OG Chocolate Chip”.
• Over-the-top stuffed cookies like the famous “Ultimate Duo”.
• Seasonal flavors, themed treats, and creative sweet innovations.
• Beautiful cookie boxes perfect for gifting and celebrations.
• A playful brand built with love, passion, and family values.
• A unique dessert experience brought straight to Aruba by lifelong island lovers.

Insider tip

Swing by for a sweet after-dinner treat when out on the town in Palm Beach. Try the “Ultimate Duo” - it’s rich, stuffed, and a fan favorite for a reason. Follow them on Instagram for more cookie delights: thecookiecastleco